February 23rd, 2016

Quick Changeover: How it Can Reduce Your Manufacturing Costs…Quickly!

Quick Changeover, also referred to as SMED, is a lean manufacturing technique designed to improve your efficiency in your manufacturing procedures. Let’s apply the technique to your converting process, and show you how it can save you time and money.

Our original intent with this post was to help manufacturers to create a “back-up” system for their operating procedures. As we delved into the topic, we realized we could accomplish that and much much more by writing about ways to improve your quick changeover.

Defining SMED and Quick Changeover

Let’s start with the big picture, and define the two terms. They tend to be interchangeable, although most Western companies tend to use the term Quick Changeover. You may also just see these referred to as “changeover.”

What is SMED?

SMED stands for Single-Minute Exchange of Dies, and it is a lean production method used to reduce the waste in your manufacturing process. Like changeover, it helps reduce the amount of changeover time from running one product to the next.

What is Quick Changeover?

Quick changeover is the amount of time taken to change a piece of equipment from producing the last good piece of a production lot to the first good piece of the next production lot. It’s essentially the same as SMED.

A Classic Quick Changeover Example

A perfect example of quick changeover is a pit-crew at a race track. How quickly the company gets the car in and out of the pit can mean the difference between winning and losing.

Watch this video of a 1950 pit crew changeover vs a 2013 changeover. The 1950 changeover takes 67 seconds. The 2013 changeover takes…well, just watch.

Screen Shot 2016-02-18 at 3.57.20 PM

How Does Quick Changeover Work in a Manufacturing Setting?

It’s hard to say how many companies that use converting machines actually track their changeover rate. It is used among medical and pharmaceutical manufacturers, who have numerous validation requirements, as well as in the tag and label industry. Contract converters also track their changeover rate.

How Can You Determine Your Costs from Delays?

In a great post on the costs of changeover for packaging operations, Velocity Equipment Solutions showed a formula for calculating how much money is lost during a changeover for automatic packaging machines. The same could be applied to any converting machines

Changeover calculation 1

They then calculated the annual cost of a changeover

Changeover calculation 2

Obviously, there’s a lot of money to be gained (or lost) by improving your Quick Changeover efficiency.

Besides this calculation, Tim McMahon, who writes A Lean Journey blog, also noted a variety of other benefits, which your organization can attach a dollar value to:

Reduce your defect rates

Because you’ll make less adjustments as part of your setup, you’ll improve quality on the first piece.

Reduce your inventory costs

As you reduce the number of batches and their sizes, you can recover operating cash and manufacturing space.

Increase your production flexibility

You’ll increase your output and boost the timeliness of your response to customer orders.

Increase your on-time delivery

You’ll be more adept at meeting customer demands.

How Do you Determine Your Quick Changeover Rate?

By conducting a Quick Changeover Analysis, which will include documenting your process and timing it, you can determine the rate we illustrated in the example above. We’ll get to the process – in general and specific to converting machines – in an upcoming section.

Is Your Goal to Reduce your Quick Changeover Time?

It should be noted that not everyone may be looking to to reduce Quick Changeover time.

Tim McMahon notes that the “purpose for reducing changeover time is not for increasing production capacity, but to allow for more frequent changeovers in order to increase production flexibility. Quicker changeovers allow for smaller batch sizes.”

Purpose of reducing changeover

This is particularly applicable to contract converters, who are running many different jobs for a wide range of clients.

However, medical and pharma manufacturers may be very interested in reducing the time.

The 7 Steps to Improve Quick Changeover with Your Converting Process

Now that we’ve defined Quick Changeover and provided you with the means to calculate its financial impact, we’d like to take you through a 7-step process to improve your Quick Changeover.

The 7-step process is detailed by Ron Pereira of the Gemba Academy in this post, but we recommend you listen to this audio interview where Ron walks us through each step.

Ron Pereira Gemba Academy - 7 steps of a Quick Changeover

We’ll take Ron’s process and apply it to a typical converting run, so you can see an example of how to pursue Quick Changeover improvement.

Step 1 – Observe the Current Converting Process

There are a variety of methods you can use to document your converting machine process. Perhaps the most efficient is to video an actual press run. Make sure you’re in alignment with union policies and you’ve got the ok from your own internal people.

You may choose to conduct one-on-one interviews with operators to determine the variations in how each operator approaches the job. You can also observe the process and take notes over the course of several shifts if an extensive video seems like overkill.

Step 2 – Categorize the Internal and External Converting Activities

An important part of SMED is distinguishing between the Internal and External activities. For a converting process, we’ve providing a few examples:

Internal activities – Internal things can only be completed when the machine is not running. For example, changing a rotary die is an example of an internal activity.

External activities – These involved activities that can be performed while the machine is running. For example, this might include moving product materials to a storage area, staging the next product materials or gathering the tools and components for the next changeover.

Step 3 – Convert Internal Activities into External Activities

Are there things that you can do with Internal Activities that could become an External Activity? Are there things that you can do ahead of time?  Are there any Internal Activities that you might be able to perform ahead of time?

Step 4 – Optimize the Internal Activities

Now that you’ve defined the activities, take a close look at how you’re performing them.  Is there a way to generate some new improvements?

For example, you may find that members of one shift are setting the die or nip pressures at different levels. Perhaps you can mark the best setting on the machine (or on a chart) so all shifts adhere to it correctly.

If you don’t have die pressure readouts on your die clamps, understand that “tight” is a matter of personal preference or strength between operators. In this case, determine the number of turns on the knobs to achieve the proper pressure.

Step 5 – Optimize the External Activities

In the same respect, you can optimize external activities as well. Is there a way to store raw material rolls closer to the converting machine? For example, you could create lists of input materials – such as tools, rotary dies, components – and have them waiting on a cart nearby for the next job.

Step 6 – Document the New Procedure So It Can be Repeated and Reproduced

When you’ve defined the Quick Changeover process, now comes the time to thoroughly document it. Not only will this serve as the basis for future improvements, but it will also provide critical back-up in case computers systems crash or paper documentation is lost.

We’ve touched on the need for medical and pharma companies to validate their processes, so many readers may be doing this already.  Part of the validation process includes keep accurate records of the process. This includes:

Create a List of Materials

What materials are you using for a job? Not only should you list the particular materials, but you should also take into account where they are stored. Your list of materials should include:

  • Specific raw materials used for the job, including empty cores for winding waste materials
  • Location the materials are stored
  • Specific tools required for changeover: rotary dies, nip rollers, bridge trucks, sensors, cables, hand tools, roll lift/crane, etc.

Document a Webpath for Each Job

Include input and out materials, sensors locations, clamp-on locations – everything along the webpath.  It’s important to know where your rolls are going, the infeed rolls, where the the materials wrap around the idlers, and where it meets up with the next station.

Many of our clients have a drawing – either one they draw out by hand or by using a CAD program – and it will be labeled so ops can take a look at it (we’ve included a CAD drawing in this post. You can also download our hand-drawn PDF as an example).

Documented webpath

Note that DeltaModTech also offers a free analysis of your current webpath that we’ll modify for improvements – this can serve as your new, improved webpath!

Document any Manual Adjustments

When the job is underway, what type of manual adjustments need to be made? Do die/nip pressures need to be adjusted?  At what level should you set a hydrojack?  Note that adjustments can vary based on a person’s strength or physical size, so it’s essential that you document the specifics.

Spindle steering adjustment

Spindle steering adjustment

 

Nip station pneumatic pressure adjustment

Nip station pneumatic pressure adjustment

 

Die Roller Hydrajack Pressure adjustment

Die Roller Hydrajack Pressure adjustment

 

Die station tracking adjustment

Die station tracking adjustment

Some specific items that might require a manual adjustment:

  • Spindle steering adjustments
  • Registration sensor and cable locations
  • Pneumatic spindle and nip pressures

Always find a way to document the particular setting, unless it can be entered into the machine itself.

Here’s an example of a spreadsheet of these documented manual adjustments.

 Documented Manual adjustments

Save the product recipe on the machine HMI (Human Machine Interface)

We call it the product recipe – these are the values that get entered in the machine computer for each job.  Depending on the HMI you’re using, you should be able to save these values as a recipe.

Use naming conventions

Typical programs will assign the most current value to your recipes, but you should establish a naming convention for the values. For example: ProductName_partsize_dateofchange

Naming conventions

Keep a list and label die tooling required

Maintain a list per job of what’s required. Tools can be turned in two different directions, so note which direction the die should be facing.  Label the die tooling required for the job so it can be easily found by new operators.

Establish Back-up Recipes

Once you’ve developed your recipes and procedures, back them up on a secondary device or network. Most machines are connected to network servers, so you can backup recipes there.  Backing up to an offsite server is also recommended.

  • Backup recipes to a secondary device or network
  • Scan webpath drawings or save them in your CAD program
  • Back up manual adjustment list digitally (scan)
  • Back up tooling list on a network drive

Create a schedule for these network backups.  You’ll likely be making ongoing changes to the processes, and these will need to be recorded.

Step Seven: Pursue Perfection

This is only the beginning. As you’ve established your Quick Changeover Process, now you can begin to improve on it, bit by bit, shift by shift.  

Dedicating yourself to the Quick Changeover Process requires an organizational commitment, but it may not be as resource intensive as some quality improvement processes.  

As Ron mentions in the interview above, you can realize changes in as a little as 1-2 weeks by following the seven step process.  And for any organization, that’s Quick!

Get a Free Customized Conceptual Layout, Including Your Specific Web Path!

Make Your Product Better and Smarter

2 responses to “Quick Changeover: How it Can Reduce Your Manufacturing Costs…Quickly!”

  1. Blaine Stambaugh says:

    Can you recommend an extendable, arm type hoist that will mount on the top of the side plate/ frame of your press?
    It will be used to assist the operator in changing die cylinders on the various stations.

  2. Delta ModTech says:

    Hi Blaine,
    We have installed custom crane hoists on several machines. We would need more information about the machine to recommend the best crane for your application. Please contact our sales group for more information. https://deltamodtech.com/contact/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *