April 10th, 2018

Choosing Right: Laser Die Cutting Vs. Rotary Die Cutting

Precision vs. durability? Cost vs. quick run capabilities? In the laser die cutting vs. rotary die cutting smackdown, there are a variety of reasons to choose one over the other – and a whole lot of grey area in between.  Let’s take a closer look at what’s right for your die cutting machine.

Before we break down the pros and cons of each option, let’s start out with a qualifier: The die cutting option you choose will depend entirely on the type of project you’re undertaking. And, as you’ll learn, there are cases when both options can be used.

But before we get to that, and an interview with die cutting expert Todd Wood of Delta ModTech, let’s take a look at some definitions of each option.

What is laser die cutting? 

image of laser die cutting converter with waste matrix rewind

Laser die cutting involves using a high-speed laser to cut through substrate. Lasers can be used to make a variety of cuts and do not require any contact with the material.

As noted by ESAB (@esabglobal), the word “LASER” is an acronym for “Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation.” You know that lasers are used in all walks of life, but here is a video that shows a laser at work in a converting application:

How Lasers Work for Cutting in an Industrial Application

 

There are only a few manufacturers of the actual laser used in laser cutting machines. 

Types of Laser Cuts

  • Ablation
  • Kiss cutting
  • Through cuts and slug removal
  • Performation
  • Drilling
  • Slitting
  • Scoring
  • Scribing and sequential numbering
  • Reject marking 

Materials Used in Laser Cutting

Image of Laser Die Cut Parts Screen Shot 2016-04-22 at 5.00.02 PM

 

  • PSA, Polyester, cork, foam, neoprene, silicone, PU, PE, PET, polycarbonate, polyethylene, polypropylene
  • Thin foil, metal
  • Ablation of metals bonded to polyester or similar substrates
  • Abrasives, adhesives, fabric, paper, plastic, rubber, textiles 

 

What is rotary die cutting? 

Rotary Die 2

Rotary die cutting involves using a customized, machined part to cut through substrate. Rotary dies can make a variety of cuts, and is known for its durability.

How Rotary Die Cutting Works in an Industrial Application

 

Types of Die Cuts

The types of die cuts are:

  • Metal to metal (also known as thru cutting)
  • Kiss cutting
  • Perfing
  • Scoring
  • Slitting

Materials Used in Die Cutting 

rotary die cutting materials

There are many materials that can be rotary die cut. The most common are: Paper, Film, Foam, Gaskets, Tapes, Magnets, Tyvek, Vinyl, and Pouch stock foil. There are many more and it is always best to have your die tooling supplier test each material to verify cutting capability. 

The Advantages of Laser die Cutting

What are the advantages of laser die cutting over rotary die cutting? Let’s take a look.  

Tough cuts, tight tolerances. The laser’s claim to fame is that it can cut through intricate, tricky patterns in which it would be difficult for a traditional rotary die cutter.

Prototype friendly, quick turnaround. Laser cutting doesn’t require hard tooling, so it’s ideal if you want to create quick prototype. You can then invest in a more durable rotary cut die down the road.

Matches up with a variety of materials.  There are a wide range of lasers so they can match up with a variety of materials.

Maintenance / Replacement costs. A rotary die may be less expensive to purchase, but it will eventually become dull and need to be sharpened and replaced. A laser will last significantly longer.

Storage. Rotary dies are heavy and require racks. It will definitely take up space and you’ll need to allocate time to organize the storage.

Flexibility. The laser can be continuously readjusted for quick runs, which is why it’s often the choice of contract converters.

User-friendly. Providing you’re trained properly on the laser’s usage, it should be significantly easier to operate.  A rotary die needs to be physically replaced when it wears down, and will require operator training for the replacement process.

New advancements. Laser technology has come a long way, and new advancements are taking place every day. We’ve listed the new lasers on the market, and more appear every day.

Instant verification. You can verify cut tests immediately.

Quicker time to market. You can upload a drawing quickly to a laser cutting machine and beginning cutting. Those recipes and programs can also be saved and easily recalled.

DeltaModTech laser expensive Pullquote

The Advantages of Rotary Die Cutting

Let’s take a look at the advantages of rotary die cutting machines in comparison to laser die cutting machines.

Difficult to cut materials. Lasers may struggle with more difficult materials. The rotary die usually cuts through any substrate at approximately the same speed. The laser speed will be dependent on the cut pattern.

Big runs. A rotary die is better for handling big production runs, as it can cut at a faster rate and ultimately a lower cost.

Less upfront costs. A rotary die cutting machine is less expensive to purchase.  

Speeds. Laser cutting moves at a slower pace. It has to adjust its cutting speed and depth with each cut, where the shape is already in the rotary die.

DeltaModTech Test Pullquote 

Side-by-Side Comparison: Rotary Die Cutting vs. Laser Cutting

Both rotary die cutting and laser cutting have advantages based on specific situations. We decided to compare them based on the various needs we see in rotary die cutting:

  Advantage:
Laser Die Cutting
Advantage:
Rotary Die Cutting
Tough cuts, tight tolerances

X

 
Difficult to cut materials  

X

Prototype friendly, quick turnaround

X

 
Matches up with a variety of materials

X

 
Maintenance / replacement costs

X

 
Big runs  

X

Less upfront costs  

X

Storage

X

 
Flexibility

X

 
User-friendly

X

 
Speeds  

X

New advancements

X

 
Instant verification

X

 
Quicker time to market

X

 

 

The Decision is in the Details

Even though there appear to be many more strengths to laser cutting than die cutting, it’s not always going to be an automatic choice.We discussed the decision-making process with Todd Wood, Project Coordinator with Delta ModTech.  Todd also shared some thoughts on why a hybrid approach can often yield the best results.

Todd Wood Interview

 

Ultimately, your decision will be driven by the project goals, costs and time constraints. It brings us back to our number one point of emphasis: When you establish effective R&D and concrete goals upfront, it allows a converting machine manufacturer to provide the best solution.

Follow these links to learn more about our laser die cutting and rotary die cutting machines.

Get a Free Customized Conceptual Layout, Including Your Specific Web Path!

Make Your Product Better and Smarter

2 responses to “Choosing Right: Laser Die Cutting Vs. Rotary Die Cutting”

  1. If you have a simple shape and a lot of items to cut out, it looks like rotary die cutting would be your best option. You mentioned that rotary machines can cut through foam, in addition to many other materials. Can you tell me how thick the foam can be without slowing down production?

    • Delta ModTech says:

      All materials are unique and need to be evaluated for which method is the best for producing a give part. Dimensional requirements and sample material or parts are required. We do not like to generalize but have customers rotary cutting foam up to 3/8 inch thick but it is all material and product dependent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *